How to Find the Best Organic Mattresses ~ 2025 Buying Guide

Last Updated on February 14, 2025

In the market for an organic mattress to help you sleep healthier? Here’s everything you need to know about the best organic mattresses available in 2025.

WHY GET AN ORGANIC MATTRESS?

I’ve been researching the health effects of common materials for years now, and one of the first places experts wary of the hundreds of industrial chemicals in our furnishings suggest focusing our attention is our mattresses.

As I’m sure you’re aware, we spend at least a third of our lives in bed, so making sure we’re not exposing ourselves to harmful chemicals while we’re sleeping is a surefire way to lessen our toxic load.

Many excellent options for organic mattresses have come out in recent years, and most are available to buy online at competitive prices.

If you’ve never bought a mattress online before, rest easy. Though you don’t try them out ahead of time in a showroom, all these natural mattresses come with a comfort guarantee, so if it turns out you choose a mattress that isn’t the best fit for your needs, you can return it or exchange it for another one.

WHAT’S IN AN ORGANIC MATTRESS?

Perhaps the better question to ask is what’s not in the best organic mattresses. Let’s start with some of the things you’ll find in a conventional mattress, and you’ll see why you want to avoid them.

More people are waking up to the fact that most mattresses on the market are made with chemicals harmful to human health.

Mattress shoppers often look only at the feel of the mattress and the price tag. The savvy ones know to consider a far more important question: What is this mattress actually made of?

A rigorous consumer watchdog organization, MADE SAFE, sought to answer that question after discovering how difficult it is to find out what mattresses are made of, as well as the health effects of those materials. Mattresses don’t generally have ingredient lists or health warnings on their labels — though they really should!

MADE SAFE’s report, Detox Your Sleep, reviews research on the health impacts of exposure to common mattress materials. It’s a pretty interesting read, if you want to check it out.

In case you’re short on time, some of the highlights are listed below.

CHEMICALS IN CONVENTIONAL MATTRESSES

MADE SAFE’s research found that conventional mattresses often include the following in their foam, fabrics, fills, and adhesives:

Flame retardants
Because conventional mattresses use highly flammable material, they’re treated with flame retardants. One especially nasty one is chlorinated tris, a carcinogen that was banned from children’s pajamas because of health concerns but is still allowed to be used in mattresses.

Flame retardants have been linked to health issues including cancer, endocrine disruption, lowered IQ, fertility problems, and thyroid dysfunction.

Isocyanates
Derived from petroleum, isocyanates have been linked to respiratory issues and skin irritation.

Volatile Organic Compounds
The EPA reports that exposure to VOCs can cause neurological issues like headaches and loss of coordination and may even damage the central nervous system, kidneys, and liver. Certain VOCs are suspected carcinogens.

Antimony
Found in some polyester fibers, antimony trioxide is a potential endocrine disruptor and possible carcinogen.

Additional Chemicals
Mattress companies are not required to reveal all the ingredients they use in materials like adhesives, so we can’t know exactly what’s in them. Many adhesives, fabrics, and foams include formaldehyde, a known carcinogen. MADE SAFE reports that mattresses may also include acetone, phthalates, and other substances associated with negative health effects.

Want to avoid spending a third of your life breathing in these chemicals? Me too!

MADE SAFE has created one of the most rigorous certifications for chemicals, so when a company pursues MADE SAFE certification, consumers can know the product was made with the healthiest, safest materials possible.

MATERIALS USED IN THE BEST ORGANIC MATTRESS BRANDS

What’s in the best organic mattresses? Carefully evaluated and certified to be free of thousands of harmful chemicals, the top organic mattresses are made with simple, naturally-derived materials, including:

• Latex
• Wool
• Organic cotton
• Metal coils

No carcinogenic or endocrine-disrupting chemicals, no petroleum-based foams.

I’ve tried three different natural mattress brands in the last decade, and they all have much to recommend them. But which is right for you will depend on how soft or firm you prefer your mattress and what your budget is.

CERTIFICATIONS TO LOOK FOR WHEN CHOOSING THE BEST ORGANIC MATTRESS

• GOTS (Global Organic Textile Standard) — The premier certification used for textiles, GOTS tells you that the textiles used were all certified organic.
• GOLS (Global Organic Latex Standard) — Similar to GOTS, but certifying that any latex used was organic
• OEKOTEX — A European certification validating that the product doesn’t contain certain harmful chemicals
• Greenguard — Greenguard evaluates materials for their potential to offgass harmful compounds like VOCs
• MADE SAFE — MADE SAFE is probably the most important certification, as it requires that the company undergo rigorous screening to determine that it contains nothing harmful. Unlike the other certifications, which may be used if one but not all the manufacturer’s suppliers have been certified, MADE SAFE guarantees that what you’re getting is actually a non toxic organic mattress. If you see MADE SAFE certification, the other certifications can be taken for granted.

For this reason all the best organic mattresses included here have gotten MADE SAFE certification. And guess what? There are only 3!

That simple fact makes the confusing process of choosing the best natural mattresses A LOT easier.

BEST ORGANIC MATTRESSES FOR HEALTHIER SLEEP

Because MADE SAFE certification is so rigorous, if you’re looking for the best organic mattresses out there, you’ll want to choose from the three brands that earned the MADE SAFE seal of approval, Naturepedic, Happsy, and Avocado.

NATUREPEDIC ORGANIC MATTRESS

Naturepedic was one of the first mattress brands to create mattresses without all the toxic chemicals in conventional mattresses. They met the most stringent certifications before many of those certifications even existed!

Naturepedic has an array of options, making mattresses with and without coils, as well as vegan options that don’t use wool.

My babies both slept for years on a Naturepedic crib mattress, and I recently got one for myself.

Price range: A Naturepedic organic mattress starts at $1199 for a twin. You can get 15% off your purchase using the code ‘savvy15’

–>Check out the options for Naturepedic organic mattresses here.

Certifications: MADE SAFE, GOTS, GOLS, Greenguard

Warranty: 10 years on Chorus, 20 years on Serenade and Eos

–> Note that Naturepedic is one of the sites that Rakuten offers cash back on, so you’ll get an additional rebate of around 4%, or about $50 on the least expensive twin. Rakuten’s rebates can vary from day to day, so you may get more.

You can join Rakuten and get a $30 bonus using this link. Find out more about saving online with Rakuten.

HAPPSY ORGANIC MATTRESS

Happsy offers only one type of mattress, which helps them keep costs down.

Price range:

The least expensive of the natural mattresses covered here, their twin mattresses start at $899, but you can save $200 with the code ‘SAVE200’, so the cost will be only $699. A queen mattress is $1399 and king is $1699.

–>Shop for Happsy’s mattresses HERE.

Rakuten had 2% cash back on Happsy at the time of this writing.

Certifications: MADE SAFE, GOTS, GOLS, Greenguard

Warranty: 20 years

Read more about Happsy in this review of their affordable non-toxic mattresses and find out more about the company here.

You can try a Happsy mattress for 120 nights to make sure it’s the right one for you.

AVOCADO ORGANIC MATTRESS

Avocado is a really cool company with a wide range of organic mattresses to choose from.

A B-Corporation, Avocado has committed to sustainability and has made their operation carbon negative, offsetting more carbon than they create making their natural mattresses. Powered by renewable energy and zero waste, this company is setting a new standard for what it means to be a green business.

Price range: Avocado’s twin organic mattress starts at just $699, and costs even less when on sale. Their queen natural mattress is $999, and king is $1299.

Like Naturepedic, Avocado has different lines at different price points.

To celebrate national sleep awareness month, Avocado is offering HealthyGreenSavvy readers a 10% discount on their purchases through March 31. Use the code ‘SAVVY’ to save on one of their excellent organic mattresses.

Certifications: MADE SAFE, GOTS, GOLS, Greenguard

Warranty: 10 years on the least expensive model, up to 25 years on other models.

They offer a 100-night trial on their entry-level organic mattress, and up to a year (!) on others.

–>Check out Avocado’s natural mattress options here.

HOW TO CHOOSE THE BEST ORGANIC MATTRESS

All the mattresses mentioned above meet the most stringent standards for health. How do you choose which is the best natural mattress for you?

There are typically a few factors that affect which organic mattress you choose:

• Cost
• Level of support
• Amount of cushioning

COST

As noted above, you can get one of the best organic mattresses starting at $699 or a bit less for a twin. Both Happsy and Avocado have pocketed coils and a latex layer for cushioning in their least expensive mattress. Naturepedic’s least expensive twin mattress is $1199, which comes down to just over $1000 when you use the discount code ‘savvy15’.

CUSHIONING

You’ll pay more as you add layers of latex cushioning. I would suggest going with the less expensive models and ordering one of the latex or wool toppers all three companies sell if you find you want a softer feel. While you can always add softness on top, if your mattress turns out to be too soft, you can’t remove layers sewn inside the mattress.

SUPPORT

Firmer mattresses and those with coils generally provide more support than all-latex mattresses.

If you’re considering an all-latex natural mattress, here’s a run-down of the pros and cons of latex mattresses below:

Pros of an all-latex mattress:

You can adjust the feel of the mattress

Multiple layers in different firmness levels let you change up the feel of the bed until you find the right one for you. If you get a king-size bed, you may have 6 pieces to play with, giving you numerous configurations to try.

All-latex mattresses hold up for a very long time

I’ve noticed our innerspring mattresses tend to acquire dips and valleys much more readily than the all-latex mattress. The latex mattress feels pretty much the same after years of use.

Cons:

May be too soft for some

You can select firmer types of latex (dunlop rather than soft talalay, both available in different densities and firmness levels), but if you need extra support, latex on its own might not work for you.

I got our latex mattress when I was pregnant, which perhaps wasn’t the wisest choice. But after I had the baby and wanted to change the firmness level, having the 6 layers to play with let me try a whole bunch of firmness options before deciding latex was just not going to do enough to support a hypermobile side-sleeper like me.

We still have all the pieces and gave that baby a super-healthy big-kid bed with three of them when she got bigger, and she loves it. Two of the other pieces have worked as toppers for the innerspring mattresses we tried after deciding all-latex wasn’t working for us.

Not for anyone with a latex allergy

If you’re allergic to latex, you’ll be looking for a latex-free natural mattress.

Often more expensive than coil mattresses

Naturepedic’s all-latex mattress starts at $1799 for a twin vs. $1199 for their least expensive mattress with coils (or Avocado’s least expensive mattress at $699)

May transfer motion more than innerspring mattresses

Our bouncy latex bed tended to transfer motion from one side the other when one of us turned over or got up, making for a less restful night’s sleep. Our innerspring mattresses do that less, helping us sleep more soundly.

OTHER TIPS FOR GETTING BETTER SLEEP

Now that you’ve detoxed your bedroom, there are other things to consider if you’d like to get better quality sleep.

Once you’ve got a comfortable organic mattress, be sure you’re not doing anything to sabotage your sleep. Put away electronics before bedtime or use a blue-light filter if you need to look at a screen before bed.

Also make sure your body is getting enough of the nutrients linked to better sleep. Here are the best foods for sleep to eat more of.

• Keep your bedroom cool (68 degrees is considered ideal)
• Soak in a hot bath with magnesium-rich DIY bath salts before bed
• Try a soothing aromatherapy blend (I absolutely LOVE this roll on from Plant Therapy)
• Get blackout curtains (added bonus: they’ll save energy on heat as well)
• Exercise every day (but not too close to bedtime)

Do you have an organic mattress? Which one did you choose and how?

Interested in other ways to reduce your exposure to toxic chemicals? Start with these action steps:

• Choose natural cleaners and laundry detergents
• Avoid canned food
• Eat real food (as opposed to chemical-filled food-like substances)
• Get a quality water filter (and consider a shower filter) to remove scores of chemicals from your water

Here are some additional ways to create a healthy home.

Pin to save this info on the best organic mattresses for later!

Best organic mattress photo credits: vadimguzhva, Naturepedic, Happsy, Avocado